Evaluation and validation of SRTMGL1 and ASTER GDEM2 for two Maghreb regions (Biskra, Algeria and Medenine, Tunisia)

In this paper, we present the comparison and validation of the Shuttle Radar Topography Mission Version 3.0 Global 1 Arc-Second (SRTMGL1) Digital Elevation Model (DEM) and the Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer Global Digital Elevation Model Version 2 (ASTER GDEM2) applied to two areas of Maghreb region (Biskra, Algeria and Medenine, Tunisia). These are the two target areas assessed in the frame of WADIS-MAR project (http://www.wadismar.eu), which is one of the five demonstration projects implemented within the Regional Programme SWIM (http://www.swim-sm.eu) and funded by the European Commission. Newly released SRTMGL1 is available for free download since October 2014 over the African continent through United States Geological Survey (USGS) web data tools. Given the previously reported issues regarding optical sources DEMs, SRTMGL1 can provide significant advantages in elevation modelling and geoscience applications, but studies regarding its quality assessment and validation are in their early infancy. We employed the two data sets in a visual and quantitative comparison and subsequently, their validation was conducted using ground control points (GCPs) collected within the target areas. Results show that SRTMGL1 presents an overall major accuracy and higher sensitivity to small-scale features and slight variations in landforms.